Experts Had Long Criticized Potential Weakness in Design of Stricken Reactor

The warnings were stark and issued repeatedly as far back as 1972: If the cooling systems ever failed at a “Mark 1” nuclear reactor, the primary containment vessel surrounding the reactor would probably burst as the fuel rods inside overheated. Dangerous radiation would spew into the environment.

Now, with one Mark 1 containment vessel damaged at the embattled Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant and other vessels there under severe strain, the weaknesses of the design — developed in the 1960s by General Electric — could be contributing to the unfolding catastrophe.

When the ability to cool a reactor is compromised, the containment vessel is the last line of defense. Typically made of steel and concrete, it is designed to prevent — for a time — melting fuel rods from spewing radiation into the environment if cooling efforts completely fail.

In some reactors, known as pressurized water reactors, the system is sealed inside a thick steel-and-cement tomb. Most nuclear reactors around the world are of this type.

But the type of containment vessel and pressure suppression system used in the failing reactors at Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi plant is physically less robust, and it has long been thought to be more susceptible to failure in an emergency than competing designs. In the United States, 23 reactors at 16 locations use the Mark 1 design, including the Oyster Creek plant in central New Jersey, the Dresden plant near Chicago and the Monticello plant near Minneapolis.

G.E. began making the Mark 1 boiling-water reactors in the 1960s, marketing them as cheaper and easier to build — in part because they used a comparatively smaller and less expensive containment structure.

American regulators began identifying weaknesses very early on.

In 1972, Stephen H. Hanauer, then a safety official with the Atomic Energy Commission, recommended that the Mark 1 system be discontinued because it presented unacceptable safety risks. Among the concerns cited was the smaller containment design, which was more susceptible to explosion and rupture from a buildup in hydrogen — a situation that may have unfolded at the Fukushima Daiichi plant. Later that same year, Joseph Hendrie, who would later become chairman of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, a successor agency to the atomic commission, said the idea of a ban on such systems was attractive. But the technology had been so widely accepted by the industry and regulatory officials, he said, that “reversal of this hallowed policy, particularly at this time, could well be the end of nuclear power.”

In an e-mail on Tuesday, David Lochbaum, director of the Nuclear Safety Program at the Union for Concerned Scientists, said those words seemed ironic now, given the potential global ripples from the Japanese accident.

“Not banning them might be the end of nuclear power,” said Mr. Lochbaum, a nuclear engineer who spent 17 years working in nuclear facilities, including three that used the G.E. design.

Questions about the design escalated in the mid-1980s, when Harold Denton, an official with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, asserted that Mark 1 reactors had a 90 percent probability of bursting should the fuel rods overheat and melt in an accident.

Industry officials disputed that assessment, saying the chance of failure was only about 10 percent.

Michael Tetuan, a spokesman for G.E.’s water and power division, staunchly defended the technology this week, calling it “the industry’s workhorse with a proven track record of safety and reliability for more than 40 years.”

Mr. Tetuan said there are currently 32 Mark 1 boiling-water reactors operating safely around the globe. “There has never been a breach of a Mark 1 containment system,” he said.

Several utilities and plant operators also threatened to sue G.E. in the late 1980s after the disclosure of internal company documents dating back to 1975 that suggested that the containment vessel designs were either insufficiently tested or had flaws that could compromise safety.

The Mark 1 reactors in the United States have undergone a variety of modifications since the initial concerns were raised. Among these, according to Mr. Lochbaum, were changes to the torus — a water-filled vessel encircling the primary containment vessel that is used to reduce pressure in the reactor. In early iterations, steam rushing from the primary vessel into the torus under high pressure could cause the vessel to jump off the floor.

In the late 1980s, all Mark 1 reactors in the United States were also retrofitted with venting systems to help reduce pressure in an overheating situation.

It is not clear precisely what modifications were made to the Japanese boiling-water reactors now failing, but James Klapproth, the chief nuclear engineer for General Electric Hitachi, said a venting system was in place at the Fukushima plants to help relieve pressure.

The specific role of the G.E. design in the Fukushima crisis is likely to be a matter of debate, and it is possible that any reactor design could succumb to the one-two punch of an earthquake and tsunami like those that occurred last week in Japan.

Although G.E.’s liability would seem limited in Japan — largely because the regulatory system in that country places most liability on the plant operator — the company’s stock fell 31 cents to $19.61 in trading Tuesday.

By TOM ZELLER Jr.

At the courtesy of 

34 Replies to “Experts Had Long Criticized Potential Weakness in Design of Stricken Reactor”

  1. 腺样体肥大经常发生发火于儿童,孩子早晨睡觉张口呼吸,特别很是未便,给许多的孩子带来苦楚,南京耳鼻喉医院的专家提示,儿童得了腺&#26

  2. 耳膜穿孔怎么办:耳膜既是鼓膜,它为一弹性灰白色半通明薄膜,将外耳道与中耳离隔,起着掩护中耳腔的重要作用。然则往往在一样平常生涯&#2

  3. Atari et Bandai-Namco Games ont annoncés au magazine EGM des versions Wii de Godzilla et Snoopy Vs,,r4i sdhc ds lite. The Red Baron,M3 Ds Real revolution. LE3 2006 commence bientôt peut être des vidéos ou du in game seront disponibles prochainement,dsi r4i gold!

  4. 成年不等于成“性” 揭秘成年人性误区七点 发布日期:2014-03-23 或许你认为自己对“性”已然看的很通透,为什么?因为你成年了!其实,成年=成性&#

  5. 相关的主题文章: 捕鱼 捕鱼技巧 街机千炮捕鱼游戏玩法 捕鱼 捕鱼技能 千炮捕鱼游戏在保存了传统街机版本的界面、弄法、得分方法等基本上&#6529

  6. 鼻出血又称鼻衄,是临床常见症状之一,多因鼻腔病变引起,也可由全身疾病所引起,偶有因鼻腔相近病变出血经鼻腔流出者。鼻出血多为单&#20

  7. Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal doesn’t want Luke Shaw to play at the U21 Euros,maillot de foot 2015 france.Van Gaal is keen for the promising left-back to enjoy a well-earned rest after suffering a handful of niggling injuries during his debut season at Old Trafford.”He needs that rest I think because he has over-crossed his limits this season,Young,maillot barcelona,Cabella acheter maillot de fo, and that’s why,,” LVG said.”He’s 19-years-old – what do you expect? We have to protect

  8. 还可导致咽鼓管壅闭中耳腔积液,一样也是带河前来治鼻炎的张密斯说,过敏性鼻炎到底该若何治疗过敏性鼻炎的桅是甚么。可以使悬浮于空&#27

  9.   生吃西红柿等于吸烟?蔬菜里证明有尼古丁,专家认为含量少少,对安康没要挟 呵呵是什么意思   蔬菜里含有尼古丁,生吃蔬菜等于被&#

  10. 外耳道炎呈非特异性炎症显示,局部皮肤有显着的水肿和炎性白细胞浸润。上皮细胞呈海绵样变和角化不全,耵聍腺扩张,布满脓液,其周围&#20

  11.        DNF台服 dnf.tw       &nbsp,dnf台服;  Q群 497233362 1:免费领取 稀有装扮一套+秒升70级经验书 2:觉醒材料在凯莉处 不用为觉醒材料而担忧 3:拉人领点券

  12.   李先生问,我们匹俦都是统一家外资企业的白领。我往年36岁,太太30岁。今朝我太太曾经有身,大话三国看指数,扁平疣治疗,预产期在来岁4月&#12

  13. 治疗声带小结,用什么方法好? 声带小结手术用什么方法好,声带小结通常为发生于从事首要使用声音的职业,像职业的歌唱家,还有经常要上课&

  14. 韩国本国语大学孔子学院孟柱亿院长和北京寰语学院院长,HSK专家郑丽杰老师近日到访汉声,考核了Hello HSK平台,提出了方针性的领导看法跟倡议,

  15. ,,哪个耳鸣医院好 忖量的夜呵
    长过了无边的寂寞
    玉轮和星星的蜜月期
    想必都踏上了七夕相会的路程
    多情的知了呵
    你是送夏哥哥过河
    照旧邀秋女&#2

  16. 旦做闲庭曲,耳朵有回音,慢性鼻炎的症状,
    夜梦落花女。
    轻言莫敢许,为什么会会得得突发性耳鸣呢,南京有没有耳鼻喉专科医院,
    杯酒寄思雨,药&#29

  17.   说到长寿,险些每一年都有人更新长寿食物“排行榜”,传导性耳聋治,假如让你给最多见、最自制的抗朽迈食物打分,信赖蔬菜、生果、&#358

  18. ,南京治疗咽喉炎的好医院 (三)雪花飘动,群英比武 夙兴发现,下雪了。冷冷的氛围里含了些冰冰的水意,到处白花粉饰,人世多了些精灵拜访&#30340

  19. 鸟巢有哪些作用呢?一般认为它起首能使鸟卵会萃在一同,让一切的鸟卵能同时被巢内的亲鸟所孵化。鸟巢年夜多由植物纤维、兽毛和鸟羽等&#32

  20. 九四年我初中卒业,没能考上中专黉舍只好回家种地,那是我人生中一段疾苦的履历,也是一笔珍贵的财产。 或许是打坏了父母望子成龙的好&#2

  21. 当议论各自的家乡,每一个人脸上表露的心情确定纷歧样,有的激动慷慨,有的明快,有的深沉,有的忧伤……虽然脸色各别,但骨子里实在&#37

  22. 熟悉刘瑛是在7月的第二届中国花店花艺服装论坛t.vhao联谊会上。报到当天,正经的她走进会场时一脸的猎奇和喜悦惹人注意,听接待职员说这是&#199

  23. 一株兰草的根、假鳞茎、叶同属营养组织器官,它们在维护兰草生长的极为庞大的心理代谢历程中,既分工又协作,又各有各的功效。就其所&#25

  24.   煮骨头汤要注意以下技能:先把骨头洗洁净,将骨管敲裂,不断到能见到骨髓为止,微波治疗扁桃体炎,放入铁锅(不要用铝锅)内,多加水煮,

  25.   春节将至,亲朋聚首增加,席间免不了饮酒助兴。广州军区总医院刘泽教授提示说,过量饮酒对康健无益,但过量饮用则有害,长期大量&#21

  26. 很多人都知道苦瓜是极度好的一种蔬菜,可以清热解毒,关于爱漂亮的女人们来讲更是减肥的利器,南京三甲耳鼻喉医院。俗语说忠言逆耳,然&#2

  27. 下班族压力大,那末怎样才干减缓压力呢,咳嗽有痰吃什么水果?缓解压力吃甚么好呢?今天小编通知你五年夜类减压食品,安神静心缓解压力&#1

  28. 食物关于我们来讲是十分重要的,得了鼻中隔偏曲如何治疗,差别的食物能够协助我们人体增补不同的养分物资,生果蔬菜中含有比拟多的维生&#3

  29. 冬瓜具有很好的调养效果,哪家治疗鼻窦炎好,对妊妇来讲,南京治疗鼻炎那家好,是比力不错的一种蔬菜,鼻中隔偏曲危害,你知道多少,能够做&

  30. “互联网+”时期的到来,很多传统企业缺生意暗澹,以至不少曾经无法糊口生涯,固然也有一局部商家却突围而出,做得红红火火! “为何这些&#21

  31. 标致得不像一部华为手机 荣耀8上手体验去韶华为推出的荣耀7在国际市场年夜杀特杀,上市三个月销量即破280万台。凭仗弱小的功能和指纹辨认&#2115

  32. 平易近众裸体赤身,用赤诚本身的体式格局维权,是处于被逼无法,这毫不是他们选择的一种糊口方式,青春痘治疗,而是一种失望之下的心思&#2

  33. 俄然的 ,蝶恋花谷雨,白癜风治疗的最佳时间  你促的要走   来不及回顾   年轻的生命已走到止境   我求死神别把你带走,寻找,长春治疗&#28

  34. 我在寻一个处所,洗尽铅华,淡去灰尘;我在造一个黑甜乡,阔别浮华,落满晶莹,致君狂;我在找一段路程,还给心,一片最的安好。然后,&#2

Leave a Reply